Your ultimate guide to the best places to buy mattresses online in 2024

Investing in a mattress is definitely worth the money — after all, we do spend a good chunk of our time sleeping.

The average American will spend 36 years in bed throughout their lifetime — but only about 53 percent actually enjoy their bed!

Of course, one way to change that is by creating the ideal bedding setup: soft sheets, quality pillows, a comfy duvet, maybe even a throw blanket and of course, a decent mattress.

The best time to make these purchases? Sleep Week, of course! Every year, the National Sleep Foundation takes time to reemphasize the importance of sleep health, at the start of Day Light Savings (March 12 this year) and in turn many bedding and sleep brands kickstart awesome savings and promotions for the weeklong event.

If you find yourself asking, “Where is the best place to buy a mattress near me” — then we have great news. You can find an incredible mattress right from the comfort of your own couch. (Yes, we mean on the Internet).

While you may not be overly eager to buy a mattress you’ve never even touched, fret not. If you don’t absolutely love the option you bought, many brands offer a 100-night trial run so you can return the mattress easily if you decide it’s not for you. Plus, many mattress companies offer advanced methods within the online shopping process to help you get exactly what you want.

Nevertheless, online shopping for a mattress has its own set of obstacles so we reached out to the Sleep Foundation to get some tips.

How to choose mattress firmness based on sleep position

• Side sleepers should look for a medium firm mattress made of polyfoam or memory foam, providing above-average contouring to the body and also helping those who wake up with body aches.
• Back and stomach sleepers may consider a more firm latex mattress that offers less contouring and more bounce.
• Combination sleepers are looking for a medium to medium-firm mattress found in hybrid mattresses that combine innerspring support and foam comfort and benefit those who sleep hot.  

Whether you’re looking for a firm mattress to help with back pain, a plush memory-foam option that makes you feel like you’re sleeping on a cloud every night or a medium-firm mattress that is the perfect amount of softness and hardness, there are tons of amazing brands that sell elite options that can be delivered right to your doorstep.

So while you may not be going into the store to test out every mattress, the industry is wide open with possibilities.

Note: make sure to look out for discounts as many of these brands participate in sales throughout the year.

Best Overall: Avocado Green Mattress

For those looking for a sustainable mattress, Avocado may be the way to go. All of their mattresses are handmade in Los Angeles and certified organic! Each bed is made with the best domestic and imported materials, including GOTS-certified organic cotton and GOTS-certified organic wool. Best of all, they’re comfortable, featuring ergonomic zones and supportive designs like you wouldn’t believe.

Warranty: Varies by mattress type

Best for Quick Shipping: Amazon

You can find plenty of great mattresses — with thousands of reviews — on Amazon.com, many of which will be delivered right to your doorstep in just two days, thanks to two-day Prime shipping. Another thing we love? That it’s truly a one stop shop retailer, especially when sleep is concerned. Besides lots of bedding to outfit your new mattress with, you can even find mattresses and bed frames bundled together for a low price!

Warranty: Varies by brand

Best Latex Mattresses: Saatva

Saatva is another excellent company to buy a mattress online. They have a plethora of different types, including their Solaire Adjustable Mattress. It comes in the typical mattress sizes, but if you’re in the market for a king or California king, the option to split the mattress is available — making it ideal for partners who like to sleep differently.

Warranty: Lifetime

Best with Customer Reviews: Nectar Sleep

Nectar offers a wide variety of options that are great for many types of sleepers and budgets.

Warranty: Lifetime

Best for Cooling Mattresses: Cocoon by Sealy

Cocoon by Sealy offers a variety of different mattresses, including their most popular “Chill Mattress.” It’s meant for sleepers who want motion isolation, conforming support and a modern feel.

Warranty: 10 years

Best Mattress Variety: Brooklyn Bedding

Brooklyn Bedding could be an excellent choice for you, too. They’re currently doing a sale, offering 25% off the entire website.

Warranty: 10 year warranty

Best for Hybrid Mattresses: Casper

Casper is one of the most popular modern-day mattress companies online that sells four choices: the wave hybrid, the nova hybrid, the original and the element.

Not convinced yet? Check out our standalone review on the brand’s new Element Pro mattress.

Warranty: 10 years

Best Supportive Mattresses: Leesa

Leesa offers eight mattresses, each offering a variety of supportive layers and design features to keep you comfortable and ache-free throughout the night. Along with having options for kids, bedding and bed bases, the brand’s Plus Hybrid Mattress is one of the best mattress options for heavier set folks that we’ve come across. Capable of supporting up to 500 pounds, the bed is engineered to not sag or sink — no matter how much you toss and turn. It’s also motion isolating and armed with gel memory foam to keep things breezy as you slumber.

Warranty: 10 years

Best for Mattresses on Sale: Wayfair

Wayfair is a great place to shop for a mattress because it has many different options — and usually at a discount! The retailer also offers a variety of name brands, which means it won’t be difficult to find your dream bed at a fraction of its original price.

Warranty: Varies by mattress brand

Best Luxury: Amerisleep

Amerisleep has three mattresses: AS2 (it’s the most popular mattress for dynamic support and back pain relief), AS3 (blends support, softness and pressure relief for all sleep styles) and AS5 (a soft mattress, offering responsive support and cushioning comfort).

Warranty: 20 years

Best Mattress Bundles: GhostBed

GhostBed not only has a variety of mattresses but bed frames. Better still, they can be purchased together, saving you money in the long run. The brand frequently has sales, too!

Warranty: 20-25 years

Best Brand Variety: Mattress Firm

Mattress Firm is another good place to look if you want to go the traditional route and shop for more than one brand, including Sleepy’s, Tempur-Pedic, Sealy and many more.

Warranty: Varies by brand

Best Motion Canceling Mattresses: Purple

Take advantage of mattress options from Purple: the brand’s classic, hybrid, hybrid premier and more. Each include a flexible grip that adapts to a sleeper’s unique shape. There is advanced edge support to keep the sides from dipping over time, white a moisture-wicking cover prevents overheating.

Warranty: 10 years

Best Budget: Walmart

Walmart sells many different mattress brands, including Zinus, Slumber, Lucid and more. Best of all, they are so affordable. Like, options under $500! While we have nothing against investing a few dollars in the right mattress, it’s nice to save when possible, especially if we need a mattress for a guest room.

Warranty: Varies by mattress brand

Best for Adjustable Beds: Tempur-Pedic

Temper-Pedic has many different mattresses online, but their most popular option — “TEMPUR-ProAdapt” — has more than 7,200 positive reviews and comes in soft, medium, medium hybrid and firm softness.

Warranty: 10 year

Best Financing: Birch by Helix

Birch is another great organic mattress company that sells one mattress with stellar airflow and breathability, optimized for pressure relief and sustainably sourced.

Warranty: 25 years

Best Sleep Trials: Awara Sleep

Awara sells one organic, latex-hybrid mattress that was designed with wrapped coil springs to provide contour and a touch of bounce for supportive sleep throughout the night.

Warranty: Lifetime

Best Memory Foam Mattresses: Bear Mattress

Bear Mattress features many different options, but the brand’s original mattress has three layers of comfort: cooling graphite-gel memory foam, responsive transition foam and high-density support foam.

Warranty: Lifetime

Best Affordable Luxury Mattresses: DreamCloud Sleep

The DreamCloud Sleep has two mattresses for sale: their original DreamCloud mattress and the DreamCloud Premier mattress.

Warranty: Lifetime

Best Luxury: Amerisleep

Amerisleep has three mattresses: AS2 (it’s the most popular mattress for dynamic support and back pain relief), AS3 (blends support, softness and pressure relief for all sleep styles) and AS5 (a soft mattress, offering responsive support and cushioning comfort).

Warranty: 20 years

Best Shopping Experience: Layla Sleep

You can’t go wrong with Layla Sleep. The brand uses cutting-edge technology with a luxurious feel to create quality and long-lasting mattresses. More importantly, if you’re not a mattress expert, the site clearly explains the difference between options, including which models are prone to sinking or have more bounce.

Warranty: Lifetime

Best Soft Mattresses: Plush Beds

Plush Beds sells a wide variety of mattresses that are as soft a cotton ball but far more supportive. While most start at medium and go up to firm (or dual firm), the breathable cotton tops of each keep things snuggly all night long. The Botanical Bliss is the most popular and coil free. However, if you prefer some spring in your slumber, check out the Signature Bliss Pillowtop mattress or the Luxury Bliss Mattress.

Warranty: Lifetime

Best Customizable Mattresses: Sleep Number

Sleep Number is a one-stop shop for mattresses, bedding and pillows. The brand offers many different options in their classic, performance, innovation and memory foam series.

Warranty: 15 years

Tips on choosing the perfect mattress while shopping online

“It’s important to consider your build (height/weight), and your sleep position (side, back, stomach, combination) when choosing a mattress,” said Logan Foley, Sleep Science Coach and Managing Editor at the Sleep Foundation. “For instance, a sleeper who is 5’1 and weighs less than 130 pounds could find a mattress more firm than someone who is 6’1 and over 230 pounds.”

“When buying online, a consumer won’t have access to a customer service representative to help them with their specific sleep needs,” Foley said. “This means they need to be more aware of what they want in a mattress than someone who shops in-store.”

Overall: The Sleep Foundation suggests a medium soft firmness level for sleepers under 130 pounds, medium firm between 130-230 pounds, and extra firm for sleepers 230+ pounds.

Why Trust Post Wanted by the New York Post

For over 200 years, the New York Post has been America’s go-to source for bold news, engaging stories, in-depth reporting, and now, insightful shopping guidance. We’re not just thorough reporters – we sift through mountains of information, test and compare products, and consult experts on any topics we aren’t already schooled specialists in to deliver useful, realistic product recommendations based on our extensive and hands-on analysis. Here at The Post, we’re known for being brutally honest – we clearly label partnership content, and whether we receive anything from affiliate links, so you always know where we stand. We routinely update content to reflect current research and expert advice, provide context (and wit) and ensure our links work. Please note that deals can expire, and all prices are subject to change.

Hunting for a headline-worthy haul? Keep shopping with Post Wanted.